Western Tanager (Piranga ludoviciana)

Western Tanager added to the LBRC Review List 11 Mar 1989 was removed from the Review List on 16 March 2013.

Accepted Records

One immature female (1982-49; was 89-97) on 18 Dec. 1982, Cameron: East Jetty Woods; Steven W. Cardiff (LSUMZ #107845; AB 37(3):310 and AB 37(4):651).

One first-year male (1983-27; was 89-98) on 23 Apr. 1983, Cameron: 1 mi. W Holly Beach; Steven W. Cardiff (LSUMZ #112121) & Donna L. Dittmann, DPM, RDP, BMM. Erroneously reported from 22 Apr. in AB 37(5):881.

One adult male (1984-064) on 28 April 1984, Cameron: Cameron, E. side of town; Ronald J. Stein. This species was added to the Review List in 1989, with hopes that the LBRC would be able to also capture older records preceding the date; it was removed on 16 March 2013.

One male (1984-25; was 91-48) on 7 Oct. 1984, Cameron: Peveto Beach Woods; Joseph P. Kleiman and Karl Overman (ph only).

Two adult males (1985-61; was 89-96) on 28 Apr. 1985, Cameron: East Jetty Woods; Steven W. Cardiff (one collected, LSUMZ #122413) & Donna L. Dittmann. Erroneously reported from 22 Apr., AB 37 (4): 651.

One adult male (89-161) on 2 Dec. 1989, Cameron: Garner Ridge; Phillip Wallace, Curtis Sorrells (AB 44(2):283).

One female or immature male (1987-11; was 89-139) on 24 Oct. 1987, Cameron: Peveto Beach Woods (Holleyman Sanctuary); John P. Sevenair and Curtis C. Sorrells (AB 42(1):91).

One immature female (89-141) on 8 Oct. 1989, Cameron: Johnsons Bayou; Steven W. Cardiff (LSUMZ 152190) (AB 44(1):108).

One immature female (89-140) on 22 Oct. 1989, Cameron: approx. 5 mi. E of Cameron; Steven W. Cardiff (LSUMZ 152191) (AB 44(1):108).

Two males (91-25) on 28 Apr. 1991, Cameron: Cameron; Phillip A. Wallace, Curtis A. Marantz, and Curtis C. Sorrells (AB 45(3):459).

Three, one female and two males (91-27), on 4-5 May 1991, Cameron: Cameron; Curtis A. Marantz (males found by Cerise Cauthron); males may have been same birds as in 91-25 (AB 45(3):459).

One male in alternate plumage (91-28) on 1 May 1991, Cameron: Hwy. 82, approx. 1 mi. W of (town of) Holly Beach; Paul E. Conover (ph) (AB 45(3):459, 510 includes ph by Conover on pg. 510).

One male in basic plumage (91-46) on 16 Dec. 1991, Cameron: Oak Grove; Ronald J. Stein (AB46 (2):278).

One female (92-39) on 10 Apr 1992, Jefferson: Jean Lafitte National Historical Park and Preserve, Barataria Preserve Unit; David P. Muth; AB 46(3): 437.

One adult male (94-59) from 15-26 Jan. 1994, Plaquemines: Fort Jackson; Joseph P. Kleiman, Phillip A. Wallace, and Steven W. Cardiff (LSUMZ159817) (FN 48(2):218).

One male (1995-119) on 11 April 1995, Jefferson: Grand Terre Island, vicinity Fort Livingston; Bob Russell (ABF cardonly). One adult female in basic plumage (1998-030) on 4 January 1998, East Baton Rouge: Baton Rouge, intersection of Lee Drive and Burbank Avenue; Christopher M. Fuller.

One male (95-39) on 11 Apr 1995, Cameron: Johnsons Bayou, chenier just W of Tenneco gas pipeline; Megan Whitman.

One adult male (1995-054) on 14 April 1995, Cameron: Johnsons Bayou, Peveto Woods Sanctuary; William R. Fontenot (card only).

One male (95-53) on 16-19 Apr 1995, Lafayette: Lafayette, 110 Zilia Street; Nettie and George Broussard; NASFN 49(3): 263, LOS News 165:11.

One immature male (95-77) on 7 Oct 1995, Jefferson: Grand Isle, E. end of island near Exxon facility, B. Mac Myers III.

One immature female (95-118) on 28 Oct 1995, Cameron: approx. 5 mi. E of Cameron; Steven W. Cardiff (LSUMZ 164916; DLD ) and Donna L. Dittmann. No. 95- 118 and No. 95-77 (above) noted in NASFN 50(1): 69 and LOS News 168: 7.

One adult male in basic plumage (96-07) on 24 Feb. 1996, Cameron: Parish Road 615 and Hwy. 82 at Calcasieu River ship channel; Matt Pontiff (ph) (FN 50(2):182; LOS 171).

One female (96-38) on 22 Apr 1996, Iberville: 4 mi. N of St. Gabriel, 435 Pecan Drive, Donna L. Dittmann; NASFN 50(3): 293, LOS News 174: 10.

One female (96-63) on 19 Dec 1996, Jefferson: Waggaman, Mississippi River batture near intersection of Modern Farms and River roads; Peter H. Yaukey; NASFN 51(3): 760.

One male (97-32) in first basic plumage on 1 Nov 1997, East Baton Rouge: Baton Rouge, Dagett Street; Daniel F. Lane (sketch) and Christopher C. Witt (ph only); FN 52(1): 74.

One (1998-08) on 26 Feb 1998, Orleans: New Orleans (Kay Radlauer residence); Phillip A. Wallace.

One male (98-11) on 10 Apr 1998, Jefferson: Grand Isle, woods behind Sureway Market; B. Mac Myers III (ph) and Phillip Wallace; FN 52(3): 343, LOS News 184: 17.

One adult male (1998-052) on 18 April 1998, Gulf of Mexico: 80 mi. S Patterson, South Marsh Island 66C oil platform, N28.64667� W91.937500�; Daniel G. Christian.

On near adult male (1998-055) on 16 May 1998, Cameron: Cameron at Courthouse; Coney & Janie Barré.

One first year male (99-02) on 24 Jan 1999, Lafayette: Lafayette, 214 Doc Duhon [W of Moss, S of Alexander streets]; Billy P. Leonard (ph).

One male (99-13) in first basic plumage from approximately 7 Feb-4 Mar 1999, St. John the Baptist: Reserve (residence of Bobby Jacob); Ronald J. Stein, Bill Bergen (ph only), R. Martin Guidry (ph taken 22 Feb), and Michael A. Seymour (ph only taken 28 Feb, published in NAB 53(2): 224); NAB 53(2): 176, NAB 53(3): 291, LOS News 187: 4.

One adult male (1999-110) on 15-25 February 1999, East Baton Rouge: Baton Rouge, 675 Wylie Dr.; James Burke.

One immature (male?) (1999-104) on 21 Nov 1999, Cameron: 1 mi. W of Johnsons Bayou on Hwy. 82; Alan Wormington.

One adult male (00-55) on 21 Nov 2000, East Baton Rouge: Baton Rouge, 722 Seyburn Ct. (residence of Joan LeBlanc); Carol Foil (ph); NAB 55(1): 64. Ms. LeBlanc indicated that this bird was present from mid-Oct to at least 30 Dec 2000 (Baton Rouge CBC), and that it was also present the previous winter (fide C. Foil).

One female (00-58) from 31 Dec 2000 to at least 12 Mar 2001, St. Tammany: Slidell, 913 Teddy Ave.; Peggy Siegert and M. Mark Swan (ph taken 26 Feb); first observation date mistakenly given as �21 Dec� in NAB 55(2): 182.

One adult male (2001-066) on 27 December 2001, East Baton Rouge, Baton Rouge, Joan LeBlanc residence on Seyburn Court; Joseph P. Kleiman.

One adult male (2002-072) on 4 January 2002, Vermilion: Vincent mini-refuge area of Crowley CBC; Kenneth V. Rosenberg.

One female (2002-068) on 20 October 2002, Cameron: Peveto Woods Sanctuary; Robert C. Dobbs.

One adult male (2002-78) on 28 Dec 2002, Orleans: New Orleans, Powers Junction (New Orleans CBC); Rosemary Seidler and Richard Hale (ph only).

One male (2005-28) from 17 Jan-2 May 2005, St. Tammany: Abita Springs, 22315 Main Street; Olga and Walter (ph) Clifton.

One male (2005-12) on 23 Apr 2005, Cameron: Hackberry Ridge, 2 mi. WSW of Johnsons Bayou School; Donna L. Dittmann (ph) and Steven W. Cardiff.

One adult male (2005-056) on 31 December 2005, St. Tammany: Abita Springs, 22315 Main Street; Walter Clifton (ph).

One male in basic plumage (2006-01) from 4-5 Feb 2006, Orleans: New Orleans, Constance Street (Leslee Reed residence); Phillip A. Wallace (ph).

One adult male (2006-008) on 3 May 2006, Cameron: Peveto Woods Sanctuary; Gary J. Pontiff and Matthew Pontiff (ph).

One female (2007-15) from at least 23 Feb-9 Mar 2007, East Baton Rouge: Baton Rouge, 2520 Olive Street; Kevin Morgan (ph).

One adult male (2007-12) on 25 Feb 2007, Orleans: New Orleans, 5530 Tullis Drive; Ed Wallace (ph). The bird was reported to have been present for at least three weeks prior to above date. This and the preceding record reported in NAB61(2):282.

One female (2007-025) on 15 April 2007, Orleans: New Orleans, City Park, Couturie Forest; Robert D. Purrington.

One immature male (2007-92) on 28 October 2007, Cameron: Willow Island, Donna L. Dittmann (ph, *) and Steven W. Cardiff (DLD 9051).

One female (2008-03) from 17-28 January 2008, East Baton Rouge: Baton Rouge; Kevin Morgan (ph). This is presumably the same returning bird, which spent the previous winter at this site.

One adult male (2008-24) on 17 May 2008, Cameron: Cameron, Cameron Courthouse; Donna L. Dittmann (ph) and Steven W. Cardiff.

One in non-breeding plumage (2008-061) on 27 December 2008, Iberville: 3.7 mi. N St. Gabriel, 545 Pecan Dr.; J.V. Remsen.

One male (2009-03) on 24 January 2009, Lafayette: Lafayette, Hwy. 342 near intersection Hwy. 719; Paul E Conover, Dave Patton (photo).

One (2009-026) from 2-9 March 2009, Jefferson: Harahan, 7304 Stoneleigh Dr.; Cathy DiSalvo (ph) and Beth Wiggins (ph only).

One female (2009-62) on 28 September 2009, Cameron: Peveto Beach Woods; Tom Finnie (ph). One female (2009-84) on 22 December 2009, Jefferson: Grand Isle; Erik I. Johnson (ph).

One male in non-breeding plumage (2009-115) on 21 November 2009, Jefferson: Grand Isle; east side Landry Ln. near playground; David P. Muth [ph].

One adult male in non-breeding plumage (2010-126) on 15 February 2010, St. Charles: St. Rose at railroad tracks; Edward J. Raynor.

One male (2010-25) 31 March-early May 2010, St. Landry: Washington; Cheryl Bordelon (ph).

One adult male (2010-20) on 24 April-1 May [Harris report date says 2 May--Ed.] 2010, Cameron: Peveto Beach Woods, BRAS Sanctuary; Jeffrey W. Harris (ph), Danny M. Dobbs, Thomas Finnie (ph), and Kevin Leigh (ph only).

One adult female (2010-23) on 26 April-2 May 2010, Cameron: Sabine NWR, Wetland Walkway; Thomas Finnie (ph) and Jeffrey W. Harris; found by Robby Bacon.

One adult male (2010-102) on 27 April 2010, Jefferson: Grand Isle, TNC Grilletta Tract; Tom Trenchard.

One adult male (2011-041; was 2011-06) on 8 January 2011, Jefferson: Harahan, Mississippi River batture near Normandy Street; Lizette Wroten (ph).

One male (2011-021) from 12-22 March 2011, Jefferson: Metairie, 63 Revelry Rd.; Tim Daigre (ph).

One (2011-106) on 22 October 2011, Plaquemines: Diamond; Devin Bosler (ph).

One female (2011-132) on 6 December 2011, St. Tammany: Mandeville, 19170 Antenor St.; Tom Trenchard.

One (2011-092) on 18 December 2011, Calcasieu: approximately 8.5 mi. S of Iowa, S/E side of Fruge Road approximately 1.5 mi. S of Fruge Road x Hwy. 14, N 30.104176�, W 93.030052�; Michael A. Seymour (ph) and Walker Wilson (ph).

One in female-type plumage (2011-136) on 21 December 2011, Jefferson: Grand Isle, TNC LSU Woods Tract; Erik I. Johnson.

One adult male (2011-093) on 30 December 2011, Lafayette: near Milton; Toddy Guidry (ph).

One adult male (2012-017) on 17 January 2012, Jefferson: Metairie; Joan Garvey (photos).

One male (2012-049) on 11 November 2012, Cameron: BRAS Peveto Woods Sanctuary; Paul E. Conover (ph).

One immature female (2012-033) on 27 December 2012, Plaquemines: Diamond; Phillip A. Wallace (ph).

One adult male (2013-010) from 2 January-13 February 2013, Orleans: New Orleans, S. Prieur and Cadiz streets; Phillip A. Wallace (ph).

One female (2013-009) on 2 January 2013, Cameron: Catoire Rd. (during Creole CBC), Melvin Weber (ph).

One in female plumage (2013-105) on 9 October 2013, Jefferson: Grand Isle TNC Lafitte Woods-Grilletta track; Mitch Foret (ph). Observation occurred after the species was removed from the Review List but the record was reviewed as a courtesy.

Unaccepted Records

One female (1995-55) on 23 Apr 1995, Cameron: Peveto Beach Woods. This observation involved a five second glimpse of the bird. As would be expected, the description is correspondingly superficial, and it also contains some anomalous details, including that the bird had an �all-dark bill.�

One in female-type plumage (1996-64) on 28 Dec 1996, �Catahoula CBC� (parish and specific locality not provided). The description did not exclude oriole species.

One male (2000-089) on 23 December 2000, Orleans: New Orleans, Chalmette Battlefield. The majority of Members agreed that the description was too superficial for acceptance.

One in female-type plumage (2004-52) on 2 Dec 2004, Vermilion: Pleasant Road, approximately 3 mi. W of Palmetto Island State Park. This record was considered unacceptable after three circulations. The observer�s description was extremely superficial, and did not explain why the bird was even a �tanager� to begin with. Although the observer is experienced, and the record involved a fairly obvious species, four members were ultimately unwilling to accept such a superficial description. The observation is reported to have lasted 1-2 minutes and members expected more detail would have been provided. The Committee was concerned that, had this record been accepted, it would essentially be a case of a �rubber-stamp� on the basis of the reputation of the submitting observer. This is not how the Committee wishes to operate, and the LBRC urges experienced observers to set an example and provide more, not less, information with their reports.

One adult male (2005-026) on 13 October 2005, St. Mary: ca 2 mi. S Intracoastal Canal bridge on Cypremort Point highway. Quite possibly correctly identified, but the description was considered too superficial.

One female or first-year male (2009-063) on 2 October 2009, Cameron: Peveto Woods Sanctuary. Viewing conditions were poor (bird was back lit) and the observer did not discuss how Summer Tanager was eliminated from consideration.