English and Scientific names:

Western Tanager (Piranga ludoviciana)

Number of individuals: 

1 female-type bird, very similar to the "pale adult female" in Sibley's Guide to North American Birds, but age unknown

Locality: LOUISIANA: 

Jefferson

Specific Locality:

Grilleta Tract, Grand Isle

Date(s) when observed:

22 December 2009

Time(s) of day when observed:  

9:00am

Reporting observer and address:

Erik I. Johnson
Lafayette, LA 70508

Other observers accompanying reporter who also identified the bird(s):

Karl Mokross

Other observers who independently identified the bird(s)

None known.  David Muth reported a Western Tanager in the area (by the cemetery) in November, but may have been a different bird.  He told me that he suspected his bird had some red/orange in the face and had more yellow in the underparts, suggesting a basic-plumaged male - thus a different individual.

Light conditions (position of bird in relation to shade and to direction and amount of light):

overcast; even light; well-lighted in the open mid-story of the forest edge

Optical equipment: 

Swarovski 10x42 EL

Distance to bird(s): 

25m

Duration of observation:

5 min

Habitat: 

coastal oak forest

Behavior of bird: 

foraging in hackberry; perch-gleaning fruit

Description:

Immediately the bulky size (relative to nearby Yellow-rumped Warblers, Ruby-crowned Kinglets, and Blue-gray Gnatcatchers) made this bird jump out.  I then saw the heavy pale bill and a two white wing bars.  The head and throat were all yellow and the undertail coverts were contrastingly yellow against a pale grayish-white belly and chest.  The upperparts were dingy olive-gray and fairly uniform except for the contrastingly white wing bars.  It was clearly a tanager (Piranga) by the shape of the bill and the wing bars were a good mark for Western Tanager.  Because both wing bars were white, this suggests a female.  According to Pyle (1997), there is a lot of variation within sexes, such that it is probably not possible to age this bird without examining molt limits and even then some birds cannot be reliably aged.

Voice:

not heard

Similar species:

Other yellowish tanagers do not have two white wing-bars and never have I seen a Scarlet or Summer Tanager with such two-toned underparts.  The heavy-set bill was classic for a tanager (Piranga) and unlike orioles (Ictera) while the bulky size eliminated other potentially confusing yellow passerines like warblers and vireos.

Photographs or tape recordings obtained?

yes, photographed by me

Previous experience with this species: 

only seen once before (a more yellow female-type in Kevin Morgan's yard in Baton Rouge) several years back, but familiar with Scarlet and Summer Tanagers in migration and on breeding grounds

Identification aids:

Sibley's Guide to North American Birds soon after observation; Pyle (1997) and Nat. Geog. 3rd Ed

This description is written from: 

memory

Are you positive of your identification? If not, explain: 

 

yes

Date and time: 

28 December 2009; 9:45pm